How to get a scholarly journal indexed in Web of Science (ESCI): requirements and step-by-step submission in 2026

1. What ESCI is and how it relates to SCIE, SSCI and AHCI

Web of Science Core Collection is the set of journals that Clarivate selects through its own editorial evaluation. Clarivate applies a single set of 28 criteria: 24 quality criteria and 4 impact criteria. The outcome determines which index a journal enters:

  • Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI): journals that meet the 24 quality criteria.
  • Science Citation Index Expanded (SCIE), Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) and Arts & Humanities Citation Index (AHCI): journals that also meet the 4 impact criteria. Clarivate calls these the flagship collections, and the index depends on the discipline.

A key point for 2026: according to the official criteria page, journals submitted for the first time are evaluated on the 24 quality criteria only and, if selected, are added to ESCI. Impact is not assessed for new submissions. ESCI is therefore currently the entry point to Web of Science for every journal.

The collections are dynamic: ESCI journals that gain impact move to SCIE, SSCI or AHCI, and flagship journals that lose impact move to ESCI. In addition, since the 2023 edition of Journal Citation Reports (JCR), ESCI journals receive a Journal Impact Factor (JIF), which used to be reserved for SCIE and SSCI. They now appear in the unified category rankings alongside the flagship journals.

2. How Clarivate evaluates journals: four stages and 28 criteria

The evaluation proceeds in stages. A journal that fails one stage does not move on to the next. Each stage has its own resubmission rules.

StageWhat is checkedOutcome if passed
Initial triageISSN, title, publisher, URL, content access, commitment to peer review, contactsMoves to editorial triage
Editorial triageScholarly content, English translations, Roman script, publication frequency, website, ethics, identified editorial board and authorsMoves to quality evaluation
Editorial evaluation: qualityContent consistency, editorial board, peer review rigor, policies, authorship, citationsAdded to ESCI
Editorial evaluation: impactCitation activity, authors’ and editors’ publication history in Web of Science, content significanceSCIE, SSCI or AHCI (currently not applied to new submissions)

The bar is high. In its JCR 2023 launch announcement, Clarivate stated that only 15% of the journals evaluated by its editorial team passed the 24 quality criteria.

3. Before you apply: triage checklist

The first two stages are the easiest to prepare for because they check objective items. Review them before you submit the journal.

3.1 Initial triage

  • Verifiable ISSN (print and/or electronic), displayed consistently. If both exist, both must be provided.
  • A distinct title consistent with the ISSN, scope, content and the community it serves.
  • An identified publisher with a verifiable physical address (not a P.O. box). If a learned society owns or is affiliated with the journal, this must be stated.
  • Journal URL and full-text access to current content.
  • Full access for the Web of Science team. For subscription or hybrid journals, Clarivate prefers IP-range access, or else a non-expiring username and password.
  • An explicit commitment to peer review or editorial oversight. Original research must undergo external peer review.
  • Contact details for the main editorial and production staff.

3.2 Editorial triage

  • Scholarly content that is mainly original, at graduate, postdoctoral or professional level.
  • English translations of all article titles and English abstracts for scholarly articles.
  • References, names and affiliations in Roman script. Any English text must be understandable to an international audience.
  • A stated publication frequency that is met (or a declared continuous or irregular schedule), with sufficient annual output.
  • An accurate website with clear navigation and access to key information: editorial board, author guidelines, review process and access model.
  • Transparent ethical requirements. If you adopt third-party guidelines such as COPE’s, you must link to them or reproduce them with credit.
  • An identified editorial board with names, affiliations and countries, including guest editors.
  • Identified authors with names, affiliations and countries. ORCID is recommended but optional.

If your journal is also aiming for other databases, most of these points overlap with our guide to getting indexed in Scopus.

4. The quality evaluation (and impact)

In the quality evaluation, a Clarivate editor examines the journal in depth. These are the aspects reviewed:

  • Consistency between the title, stated scope, editorial board, authorship and published content.
  • An editorial board whose size and composition suit the publication volume.
  • Content that follows the journal’s stated policies, and website information that is accurate and up to date.
  • Adequate peer review. Warning signs include weak rigor, articles outside the journal’s scope and irrelevant citations.
  • A well-defined scope and aims. If grant funding is common in your field, funding acknowledgements should be included.
  • Editorial policies aligned with recognized practices, such as COPE’s Core Practices, and articles that follow their discipline’s standards.
  • Authors with relevant affiliations, geographic diversity and a publication record.
  • Adequate citation of the literature in the field.

The impact evaluation uses citation activity as its main indicator: the number and sources of citations and their stability over time. It also takes into account the publication history of authors and editors in Web of Science and the significance of the content, for example a regional focus or an underrepresented specialty. As noted above, it is not currently applied to new submissions. ESCI journals are re-evaluated for impact when Clarivate’s internal monitoring detects citation activity that warrants it. No request is needed.

5. Step by step: how to submit your journal for evaluation

  1. Check that the journal is not already indexed. Look it up in Clarivate’s Master Journal List. The Publisher Portal is only for journals not yet in Web of Science Core Collection.
  2. Self-assess against the 24 quality criteria. Review the website, policies, English abstracts, references and the regularity of recent issues.
  3. Make sure you have enough content. Clarivate sets no minimum number of articles, but the journal must have published enough to show its full scope. Print-only journals are not currently accepted.
  4. Request access to the Web of Science Publisher Portal. Only publishers can submit journals. Editors and board members should go through their publisher, except for self-published journals, whose editor or primary contact can be granted access. Every request goes through verification.
  5. Prepare the form data: title, ISSN, URL, editor-in-chief, journal and publisher countries, publisher name and address, languages, first year of publication, frequency, number of research and review articles in the last calendar year, most recent issue, publication model, partner society, ownership, suggested category, peer review and ethics policy URLs, plagiarism checking, DOI and numbering practices, access details and contacts.
  6. Submit the request. The form checks the initial triage criteria and gives immediate feedback on eligibility. Submission and evaluation are free of charge.
  7. Track the status on the portal dashboard (Pending, Under Evaluation, Accepted, Rejected). Messages from the editorial team go to the editorial contact you provided, who may not be the person who submitted.

Clarivate does not publish an evaluation timeframe. According to the portal FAQ, it depends on the editors’ priorities and workload.

6. Rejections, waiting periods and appeals

If the journal fails a stage, the waiting period (embargo) before you can resubmit depends on the stage:

SituationWaiting period before resubmission
Fails initial triageNo waiting period
Fails editorial triage (first time)No waiting period
Fails editorial triage a second consecutive time1 year
Fails the quality evaluationAt least 2 years
Removal of an already indexed journalAt least 2 years from notification of the decision

Appeals: only the publisher can appeal, by sending a PDF with the official form to ed***************@*******te.com. Appeals are not accepted after a first editorial triage failure; in that case, fix the issues and resubmit. Improvements made after the rejection are not considered either, because the appeal must show that the journal already met the criteria. The appeal decision is final and there is no set timeframe.

Common reasons for rejection, based on the criteria themselves:

  • Missing English titles or abstracts, or references not in Roman script.
  • Late issues or a stated frequency that is not met.
  • An outdated or incomplete website: editorial board without affiliations, missing or contradictory policies.
  • Content outside the stated scope or authorship with little geographic diversity.
  • Weak peer review or irrelevant citations.

7. After acceptance: technical evaluation and JIF

Editorial acceptance is followed by a technical evaluation of the files. Once it is passed, the journal is activated and Clarivate sends the final acceptance letter. Main requirements:

  • FTP delivery (preferred): unsecured full-text PDFs plus XML. XML alone is not supported: full-text XML must be accompanied by the PDFs. If you need to produce XML, see our Word to JATS XML guide.
  • Online access as an alternative: unsecured full-text PDFs, accessible via IP or a username and password.
  • A unique identifier for each work: continuous pagination, article number or DOI. Registering DOIs with Crossref meets this requirement.
  • A prompt response: the journal fails the technical evaluation if the publisher does not reply in time.

Once indexed, you must report changes of publisher, URL, title or frequency through the Data Change Request Form. If Clarivate receives no content for 24 consecutive months, it may remove the journal.

JIF: journals accepted before 1 January that are still covered when JCR production begins in March are eligible for the JIF and the Journal Citation Indicator (JCI) in the June release. Partially indexed ESCI journals do not receive journal-level metrics.

8. How Index can help

At Index we work with scholarly journals preparing to enter databases such as Web of Science. With our free indexing diagnostic we review your journal against the triage and quality criteria. Index Platform covers editorial management, documented peer review and the journal website, and as a Crossref Sponsor we register DOIs for your articles. Index Production generates PDF, HTML and JATS XML ready for technical delivery.

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to submit a journal to Web of Science?

Nothing. Clarivate charges no fee for a Publisher Portal account or for journal evaluation.

Can I apply directly for SCIE or SSCI?

No. New submissions are currently evaluated on the 24 quality criteria only and enter ESCI; moving to SCIE, SSCI or AHCI depends on Clarivate's internal impact re-evaluation.

Do ESCI journals have an impact factor?

Yes. Since JCR 2023, ESCI journals receive a Journal Impact Factor and now appear in the unified category rankings.

How long does the evaluation take?

Clarivate does not publish a timeframe: it depends on its editors' priorities and workload. You can track the status on the Publisher Portal dashboard.